Visuel and semiquantitative analysis of Tc-99m dmsa scintigraphy in children with pyelonephritis

Abstract

AimThe aim of the study is to evaluate a quantitative method in compari-son with a visual method based on 99mTc-DMSA renal planar scintigraphy performed during pyelonephritis (PN).MethodA total of 21 children (6,6±3,2 y old (mean±SD)) were examined by 99mTc-DMSA scintig-raphy during (DMSA1) and 12,4±6,8 month (mean±SD) after (DMSA2) PN. Two levels of interpretation were performed independently: first, a visual analysis to classify the kidneys by considering the evolution between DMSA1 and DMSA2, and second, a semiquantitative analysis of DMSA1 and DMSA2. A visual method of kidney evaluation, 9-point visual analysis of each kidney was performed. A kidney was considered normal when the score was ≥7. Renal scarring was defined as a score of <7 on DMSA1 and DMSA2, and 2 groups were obtained normal(N) and defective(DF). Semiquantitative analy-sis of kidney evolution; was performed to an automatic threshold (%20-80) for the kidney and then calculating ratios of the count density and number of pixels (nC%= C in a given isocount/ C in a 20% isocount, nS%=S in a given isocount/S in a 20% isocount).ResultsFor the semiquantitative analysis, the nC70 ve nS70 ratio was considered the best index to classify the kidneys by considering the evolution between DMSA1 (to determine which kidneys N or DF group) (table1). When this nC70 ratio was used a cutoff value of 0,34, it was able to differentiate between N and DF groups with a sensitivity of %55, a specificity of %100. According to the semiquantitative analysis of DMSA-2, when the cutoff value of C70% (0.36) was taken into consideration, 12 of 15 kidneys were in the N group, and 14 of 27 were in the DF group. As a result, a group change occurred in 16/42 (%38) kidneys.ConclusionWe concluded that the assessment of DMSA scintigraphy might show significant inter-observer variation and that there was a need for quantitative parameters to make more objective evaluations.

Keywords

Additional Information

Publisher’s Note
Bayrakol MP remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional and institutional claims.

Rights and Permissions

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License (CC BY-NC 4.0). To view a copy of the license, visit https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/

View full license details →