Letter to the Editor
We read with interest the article titled “Evaluation of the Appropriateness of Forensic Reports Prepared in the Emergency Department and the Deficiencies Identified,” by Bozkurt et al., published in your journal 1. We thank the authors for sharing their experience. While discussing errors in forensic reports, the authors did not evaluate the effects of bone fractures on vital functions, which should be documented in the conclusion of these reports. We consider this omission to be a limitation of the study and would like to draw attention to this issue.
Trauma is a serious public health problem that particularly affects the young population and ranks among the leading causes of death 2. Motor vehicle occupant accidents, pedestrian traffic accidents, falls, physical assaults, occupational accidents, penetrating or sharp-force injuries, motorcycle accidents, firearm injuries, and other suspected traumatic events are considered forensic cases. In addition to trauma, sexual assault and intoxication cases, such as carbon monoxide poisoning, which is a major problem in our country, are also classified as forensic cases 3,4. Reporting such cases to the judicial authorities is among the physician’s legal responsibilities.
The requirements for preparing forensic reports have been established in accordance with Turkish Penal Code No. 5237, Criminal Procedure Code No. 5271, and the new regulations issued under these laws 5. The conclusion of a forensic report must state whether the injury poses a threat to life, whether it can be treated with a simple medical intervention, and how any fractures affect the patient’s vital functions. Bone fractures are classified according to their effects on vital functions as mild (1 point), moderate (2-3 points), or severe (4-6 points). Because joint dislocations are anatomical abnormalities of the skeletal system, they are also evaluated within this classification.
When multiple bone fractures are present, a scoring method is used to determine their combined effect on vital functions. The severity score of each fractured bone should be determined, each score should be squared, the squared scores should be added together, and the square root of the resulting total should be calculated. If the result contains a decimal fraction greater than 0.5, it should be rounded up to the next severity grade.
In a study investigating deficiencies in forensic reports, we believe it would have been appropriate to examine whether the legally required effects of fractures on vital functions were documented in forensic cases involving bone fractures. Including this assessment would have strengthened the study.
We congratulate Bozkurt et al. on their valuable contribution and extend our respects.
Additional Information
Publisher’s Note
Bayrakol MP remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional and institutional claims.
Rights and Permissions
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License (CC BY-NC 4.0). To view a copy of the license, visit https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/
About This Article
How to Cite This Article
Yusuf Emrah Eyi, Ümit Kaldırım, Salim Kemal Tuncer. The effect of bone fractures to the vital functions and the place in judicial reports. J Clin Anal Med 2015;6(1):135-135. doi:10.4328/JCAM.2142
Publication History
- Received:
- 10.11.2013
- Accepted:
- 20.11.2013
- Published Online:
- 01.01.2015
- Printed:
- 01.01.2015